{"ok":true,"checkedAt":"2026-06-02T19:15:18.588Z","profileVersion":"moral-trade-evaluation-v0.3-2026-05","purpose":"Public evaluation contract for Moral Trade protocol quality, copilot assistance, privacy safety, explanation usefulness, fairness slices, redacted deviation review logs, and human-review reliability.","cadence":"monthly_public_aggregate","validation":{"status":"pass","validatorName":"moral-trade-evaluation-profile","validatorVersion":"moral-trade-evaluation-validator-v0.3","profileVersion":"moral-trade-evaluation-v0.3-2026-05","checks":[{"id":"required-metrics","label":"Codex and reviewer quality metrics","status":"pass","evidence":"draft_completion_rate, time_to_valid_draft, blocked_proposal_precision, privacy_leakage_incidents, explanation_helpfulness, reviewer_efficiency_minutes, false_match_rate, subgroup_surfacing_parity, human_overrule_rate, appeal_overturn_rate, evidence_review_sla, duplicate_proof_miss_rate, unresolved_dispute_share"},{"id":"privacy-boundaries","label":"Privacy-safe measurement boundaries","status":"pass","evidence":"aggregate_only_by_default, no_raw_private_wish_text, no_contact_details, no_source_note_leakage, small_cell_suppression, deviation_review_log_redacted, free_text_quote_requires_consent"},{"id":"cohort-slices","label":"Fairness and review slices","status":"pass","evidence":"trade_format, cause_area_pair, geography_bucket, verification_method, privacy_stage, new_vs_returning_participant, consented_demographic_slice, optional_governed_sensitive_attribute"},{"id":"promotion-gates","label":"Rollout promotion gates","status":"pass","evidence":"shadow_mode, assist_mode, guarded_automation, human_controlled_decisions"},{"id":"zero-incident-targets","label":"Privacy and duplicate-proof targets","status":"pass","evidence":"privacy_leakage_incidents and duplicate_proof_miss_rate have zero-oriented targets."},{"id":"evaluation-tests","label":"Evaluation test hooks","status":"pass","evidence":"evaluation_profile_validator, workflow_quality_audit, surfacing_parity_audit, surfacing_deviation_review_log, ux_readiness_audit, health_route_contract_smoke, privacy_metric_boundary_smoke, promotion_gate_contract_smoke, public_technical_spec_smoke"},{"id":"sample-audits","label":"Deterministic sample evaluation audits execute","status":"pass","evidence":"surfacing pass; reviewed deviations 2; ux pass; workflow pass"}],"blockers":[]},"publicContract":{"metrics":[{"key":"draft_completion_rate","direction":"increase","target":"increase_without_higher_blocked_precision_loss","publicReporting":"aggregate_only"},{"key":"time_to_valid_draft","direction":"decrease","target":"median_down_or_explained_before_promotion","publicReporting":"aggregate_only"},{"key":"blocked_proposal_precision","direction":"increase","target":"reviewer_confirmed_precision_not_lower_than_prior_period","publicReporting":"aggregate_only"},{"key":"privacy_leakage_incidents","direction":"decrease","target":"zero_confirmed_incidents","publicReporting":"aggregate_with_zero_allowed"},{"key":"explanation_helpfulness","direction":"increase","target":"median_rating_not_lower_than_prior_period","publicReporting":"aggregate_only"},{"key":"reviewer_efficiency_minutes","direction":"decrease","target":"median_down_or_explained_without_higher_overrule_rate","publicReporting":"aggregate_only"},{"key":"false_match_rate","direction":"decrease","target":"decrease_without_privacy_leakage_increase","publicReporting":"aggregate_only"},{"key":"subgroup_surfacing_parity","direction":"band","target":"investigate_and_log_material_slice_gaps_before_rollout","publicReporting":"aggregate_thresholded"},{"key":"human_overrule_rate","direction":"band","target":"stable_or_explained_by_policy_changes","publicReporting":"aggregate_only"},{"key":"appeal_overturn_rate","direction":"band","target":"publish_with_challenge_context","publicReporting":"aggregate_only"},{"key":"evidence_review_sla","direction":"increase","target":"meet_or_explain_public_sla","publicReporting":"aggregate_only"},{"key":"duplicate_proof_miss_rate","direction":"decrease","target":"zero_unexplained_misses","publicReporting":"aggregate_with_zero_allowed"},{"key":"unresolved_dispute_share","direction":"decrease","target":"decrease_or_publish_reason_codes","publicReporting":"aggregate_only"}],"cohortSlices":["trade_format","cause_area_pair","geography_bucket","verification_method","privacy_stage","new_vs_returning_participant","consented_demographic_slice","optional_governed_sensitive_attribute"],"surfacingParityAuditDefaults":{"minCellSize":5,"maxAbsoluteGap":0.2,"sliceKeys":["trade_format","cause_area_pair","geography_bucket","privacy_stage","optional_governed_sensitive_attribute"]},"uxReadinessAuditDefaults":{"minStartedDrafts":5,"maxMedianTimeToValidDraftMinutes":30,"minExplanationHelpfulMedianRating":4,"maxReviewerMedianMinutesPerDecision":20,"maxReviewerOverruleRateIncrease":0.03},"sampleAudits":{"surfacingParity":{"status":"pass","eligibleCount":20,"surfacedCount":9,"overallSurfacingRate":0.45,"reviewedDeviationCount":2,"unreviewedDeviationCount":0,"deviationReviews":[{"cellKey":"geography_bucket:us_east","reviewerRole":"operator","reviewedAt":"2026-05-20T12:00:00.000Z","outcome":"remediated","reasonCode":"sample_rule_weight_rebalance"},{"cellKey":"geography_bucket:us_west","reviewerRole":"external_reviewer","reviewedAt":"2026-05-20T12:15:00.000Z","outcome":"accepted_with_monitoring","reasonCode":"sample_counterpart_pool_mix"}],"blockers":[]},"uxReadiness":{"status":"pass","currentPeriod":"2026-05","previousPeriod":"2026-04","blockers":[]},"workflowQuality":{"status":"pass","period":"2026-05","blockedProposalPrecision":0.9167,"falseMatchRate":0.15,"humanOverruleRate":0.2222,"overruleReasonCoverageRate":1,"blockers":[]}},"privacyBoundaries":["aggregate_only_by_default","no_raw_private_wish_text","no_contact_details","no_source_note_leakage","small_cell_suppression","deviation_review_log_redacted","free_text_quote_requires_consent"],"promotionGates":["shadow_mode","assist_mode","guarded_automation","human_controlled_decisions"],"evaluationTests":["evaluation_profile_validator","workflow_quality_audit","surfacing_parity_audit","surfacing_deviation_review_log","ux_readiness_audit","health_route_contract_smoke","privacy_metric_boundary_smoke","promotion_gate_contract_smoke","public_technical_spec_smoke"]},"blockers":[]}